BRUSSELS, BELGIUM – FEBRUARY 19: Executive Vice President of the European Commission for a Europe … [+]
A couple of interesting events happened in the venture capital industry last week, that tell us much about how capital flows, and the impact it will have on our society.
In Paris the Sista Fund investment conference took place, the aim of which is to focus attention on the need for the venture industry to provide capital to female founders, and additionally to support female investors. Some of the statistics flagged at the conference are startling –across Europe just 7% of start-up funding goes to female-founded start-ups, and for larger growth companies, less than 1% of large funding tickets (Eur 50mn and more) went to all-female founders in 2022.
Then, in the UK, the Black Seeds fund – a VC fund designed to raise capital for black business founders in the UK raised a total of GBP 5mn. Sadly, this is a miniscule amount of money compared to the size of funds across the industry, not to mention the amount that is wasted on projects of pure fantasy (for a more informed view on this please see the excellent Sinéad O’Sullivan’s recent articles on space and crypto funding in the FT).
At the same time, four French ‘AI bros’ whose new venture Mistral.AI has only been up and running for four weeks received some Eur 105 mn in funding for their venture at a valuation of Eur 240mn. Given the difficulty of raising funds at the moment this is an impressive raise, reflecting both the background of the team and the eco-system of state, business, media and entrepreneurs they have backing them, most of whom are French, highlighting the highly ‘networked’ side of French business.
Mistral raises Eur 105
However, that Mistral.AI can raise Eur 105mn in a few weeks, and Black Seeds takes in only USD 5mn, and no-one is willing to give have the ‘better’ half of the population investment capital, is not a good thing. On one hand it shows how capital gravitates faddishly to the prospect of financial return rather than economic return, and it also shows that while the majority of VC funds and investors wrap themselves in the banners of sustainability/equality and ESG, they are shy of committing real capital to these causes.
In an age where developed countries want to attract qualified migrant workers, and where productivity gains are in short supply, ‘diverse’ (by which I mean ‘not AI bros’) founders need to be able to access investment capital.
A cynical response to the above development is for female entrepreneurs for instance, to cloak their projects in AI, and I suspect that this is already happening such that mind-numbingly, every pitchdeck contains multiple mentions of the word ‘intelligent’. A better piece of advice for VC funds and entrepreneurs is to follow the example of Mistral. AI and build an eco-system of government, corporate and entrepreneur supporters. The best VC’s that I know have done this.
Algo Justice
Another angle of attack is AI itself, and specifically the data that various AI applications run on. Some years ago, I wrote about Joy Buolamwini’s Algorithmic Justice League that seeks to adjust algorithms for the biases they are programmed with. To be very speculative here, a corrective approach to AI could be taken a step further and have algorithms programmed exclusively by women, for application in female specific cases in industries like insurance and health, and to have guardrails also programmed by women. Such an approach might make the AI craze more responsive to different segments of society.
The impact of AI has already become an area of intense focus and last week the EU Parliament signed off the EU AI Act, whose main contribution is to divide the application into four pillars from harmless to very harmful (akin to China’s use of AI for social credit scoring). There has been some backlash against this already from businesses across multiple sectors that apply AI and who may find themselves being classified as AI companies (and hence liable to the regulation).
The other group to protest is unsurprisingly, the French AI bros, who fear the Act will crimp their creative flair. With a growing number of Emmanuel Macron’s former ministers joining VC firms and start-ups, I fear the AI bros might win again.
